“I’m #1 in Google. Why am I not #1 on ChatGPT?”
Many CEOs and CFOs are asking this very question as they watch supposedly “guaranteed” search traffic vanish — their companies spent decades and millions of dollars securing the #1 spot on Google and they waking up to find they are effectively invisible.
They are winning the “Search War” but losing the “Answer War.”
I recently performed a series of recursive AEO (Answer Engine Optimization) audits across the FinTech, CRM, and Cybersecurity sectors.
The results were chilling: Multi-billion dollar category leaders are being systematically “ghosted” by ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini.
While their rankings on Google look fine, the AI agents that now drive 50% of all B2B software research act like these brands don’t exist.
The 2026 Wake-Up Call: If the AI engines haven’t indexed your “Entity Data” correctly, you aren’t just ranking lower—you are being categorized out of existence.
The 50% Tipping Point: Your Buyers Have Moved On
The latest 2026 research data from G2 and Forrester confirms a massive shift: 50% of B2B buyers now start their vendor journey in an AI chatbot rather than a search engine. In just four months, this behavior jumped by over 70%.
Related Reading: Learn more about how to navigate this shift in my guide to The Personal Assistant Pivot: Optimizing for AI Search in 2026.
When a CTO asks ChatGPT, “Who is the most innovative leader in AI-driven cybersecurity posture management?”, they aren’t looking for a list of blue links. They are looking for a recommendation. If your brand isn’t in that summary, you’ve lost the deal before you even knew it was on the table.
One Brand, Three Different “Truths”
The “Inconsistency Gap” exists because the three major AI engines look for entirely different signals of authority. If you optimize for one, you are likely blind to the others.
- Google Gemini (The Legacy Librarian): Favors traditional Domain Authority. If you have 20 years of SEO baggage, Gemini will find you, but it might label you as a “legacy” tool.
- ChatGPT (The Consensus Machine): Prioritizes “Earned Authority.” It scours Reddit, G2, and industry journals. If the web consensus doesn’t cite you as an innovator this year, you’re a ghost.
- Perplexity (The Fact-Checker): Demands technical transparency. It looks for
llms.txtfiles and deep Schema markup. Without a machine-readable “Handshake,” Perplexity will pass you over for a better-structured competitor.
Case Study: The $30 Billion “Ghost”
During my audit, I identified a titan in the Cybersecurity space—a company with a $30B+ market cap. On Google, they own the “Zero Trust” and “Cloud Security” keywords. They are an undisputed leader.
However, when I asked ChatGPT for the “most modern AI-driven” solution in their niche, they were nowhere to be found. The crown was handed to smaller, nimbler rivals. The AI had “pigeonholed” the titan as a legacy network tool. Their innovation was erased because their Entity Data was outdated.
The 90-Day AEO Roadmap
Closing this Inconsistency Gap is the most urgent task for any CMO in 2026. This is why I have developed a specialized 90-Day AEO Optimization Package designed to move your brand beyond static keywords and into Active Answer Authority:
- Recursive Audit: Identify where the AI is “hallucinating” your brand as a legacy player or ignoring you entirely.
- Technical Handshaking: Implement 2026-standard machine-readable files (
llms.txt) and advanced JSON-LD schema to tell the AI exactly what you do. - Citation Scaling: Bridge the ‘Identity Gap’ by securing mentions in the high-trust platforms that the AI engines actually use to verify who is a leader in your category
Is Your Brand an AI Ghost?
Is your brand missing from the AI results that matter most to your pipeline? Don’t let your competitors own the “Answer Economy.”
Schedule your 90-Day AEO Consulting Meeting here to ensure your brand appears correctly across all major AI platforms.
As Founder of The SEO System, Richard delivers strategic consulting and builds high-performing teams that drive measurable growth, search authority, and long-term search equity.
Richard is currently accepting select clients for SEO and AEO consulting. Learn more at https://richardcummings.info/consulting.html
- The AI Inconsistency Gap: Why Your Brand is Winning on Google but Losing the “Answer War” - February 26, 2026
- The Personal Assistant Pivot: Optimizing for AI Search and AEO in 2026 - February 26, 2026
- The Ultimate Guide to Dental SEO: How to Rank Higher & Attract More Patients - March 10, 2025